Today's Wish for Season 8
May. 24th, 2012 08:49 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
hells_half_acreOkay, so usually I don't do this, but I'm going to share with you a wish for Season 8...
Now, I won't be mad if they don't do this, because just because it's my idea, does not mean it's a GOOD idea. It might in fact be a horrible idea, but I like it. I think it's delectably torturous.
Basically, I want Cas to be psychically connected with Sam. I have reasons:
It would explain, in part, how the transfer of Sam's hell-damage worked. Because as of right now, that doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Sam's SOUL was damaged, and you can't break the soul...so Cas couldn't have taken a part of Sam's soul in with him. So, what if he interrupted the message board between soul and brain? He's diverting the bad calls to his own angel-brain.
This might not be the best fix-it idea, but it DOES lead to some interesting scenarios...
For instance, we know that Cas can partially read thoughts/minds while he is in the same room as the Winchesters. He did so to Dean the very first time he met him. Or at least, he could get a general sense of emotion "You don't think you deserve to be saved." If he WERE connected to Sam, then he could possibly sense Sam's thoughts even when they are great distances apart...like, when Cas is trapped in Purgatory and Sam is very very sad on earth.
And I swear to god, I'm not a Sassy-shipper (not that there's anything wrong with that), I just really like exploring the dynamic between Sam and Castiel, because Cas is predominately Dean's friend, not Sam's...yet Cas has developed a huge respect for Sam, and Sam is/was a Cas fanboy when they first met...and yeah...I'd like some more Cas and Sam scenes/feelings.
I know Show doesn't give us much, because Sam and Cas' friendship isn't actually as tumultuous as Dean and Cas' friendship - mainly because Dean is just a tumult-machine. I mean, compare "You broke my brother and you broke the world and you better fix both AND apologize before I even THINK of forgiving you, you righteous bastard!" to "Well, you broke my head and caused me months of anguish and nearly killed me, but you shouldn't have hurt yourself to fix me - that's too much, man. And you broke the world, but hey, who hasn't? I'm not going to hug you, but I will thank you for accidentally nearly killing us all, and me especially, because I know you did it out of love. :)" I'm telling you, those side-burns are trying to tell us something - Sam is a goddamn hippie.
Anyway, it would be HORRIBLY torturous, because that connection would only be one way. Cas could keep it to himself or he could tell Dean, but either way, he'd get a front row seat to Sam's grief/desperation on earth...all the while Cas and Dean are trying to survive in Purgatory.
Now, mind you, this doesn't HAVE to be a psychic connection thing...I just favour it because of the problem with 7x17 (as I see it). This same scenario COULD work with prayer. Sam could be praying to Castiel, and Cas could hear him but be trapped and not able to answer.
Of course, from listening to the commentary on Merlin, I know how hard filming "psychic" events can be...but at the same time, from watching Merlin, I know that it CAN be done.
Mainly, I guess I just like the idea of a one-way message system and how horribly frustrating and heartbreaking that could be.
Anyway, that's my wish for today. I'll probably change my mind tomorrow, or in a couple of hours, and think that it's dumb.
Now, I won't be mad if they don't do this, because just because it's my idea, does not mean it's a GOOD idea. It might in fact be a horrible idea, but I like it. I think it's delectably torturous.
Basically, I want Cas to be psychically connected with Sam. I have reasons:
It would explain, in part, how the transfer of Sam's hell-damage worked. Because as of right now, that doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Sam's SOUL was damaged, and you can't break the soul...so Cas couldn't have taken a part of Sam's soul in with him. So, what if he interrupted the message board between soul and brain? He's diverting the bad calls to his own angel-brain.
This might not be the best fix-it idea, but it DOES lead to some interesting scenarios...
For instance, we know that Cas can partially read thoughts/minds while he is in the same room as the Winchesters. He did so to Dean the very first time he met him. Or at least, he could get a general sense of emotion "You don't think you deserve to be saved." If he WERE connected to Sam, then he could possibly sense Sam's thoughts even when they are great distances apart...like, when Cas is trapped in Purgatory and Sam is very very sad on earth.
And I swear to god, I'm not a Sassy-shipper (not that there's anything wrong with that), I just really like exploring the dynamic between Sam and Castiel, because Cas is predominately Dean's friend, not Sam's...yet Cas has developed a huge respect for Sam, and Sam is/was a Cas fanboy when they first met...and yeah...I'd like some more Cas and Sam scenes/feelings.
I know Show doesn't give us much, because Sam and Cas' friendship isn't actually as tumultuous as Dean and Cas' friendship - mainly because Dean is just a tumult-machine. I mean, compare "You broke my brother and you broke the world and you better fix both AND apologize before I even THINK of forgiving you, you righteous bastard!" to "Well, you broke my head and caused me months of anguish and nearly killed me, but you shouldn't have hurt yourself to fix me - that's too much, man. And you broke the world, but hey, who hasn't? I'm not going to hug you, but I will thank you for accidentally nearly killing us all, and me especially, because I know you did it out of love. :)" I'm telling you, those side-burns are trying to tell us something - Sam is a goddamn hippie.
Anyway, it would be HORRIBLY torturous, because that connection would only be one way. Cas could keep it to himself or he could tell Dean, but either way, he'd get a front row seat to Sam's grief/desperation on earth...all the while Cas and Dean are trying to survive in Purgatory.
Now, mind you, this doesn't HAVE to be a psychic connection thing...I just favour it because of the problem with 7x17 (as I see it). This same scenario COULD work with prayer. Sam could be praying to Castiel, and Cas could hear him but be trapped and not able to answer.
Of course, from listening to the commentary on Merlin, I know how hard filming "psychic" events can be...but at the same time, from watching Merlin, I know that it CAN be done.
Mainly, I guess I just like the idea of a one-way message system and how horribly frustrating and heartbreaking that could be.
Anyway, that's my wish for today. I'll probably change my mind tomorrow, or in a couple of hours, and think that it's dumb.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 04:04 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 04:12 am (UTC)I suppose he could somehow discover it, or Cas could do something at his end to make it a two-way connection...that'd be interesting!
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 04:29 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 04:32 am (UTC)And yeah, I think they could do it. And if they don't, hopefully they do something even better. :)
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:01 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:05 am (UTC)I'm kind of hoping that Cas CAN'T come and go as he pleases...because that would mean that he can get Dean out. Also, it doesn't make that much sense since it took them so long to find Purgatory in the first place. It has to be a harder nut to crack than Heaven and Hell.
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:21 am (UTC)We know a portal can be opened to Purgatory (Lovecraft did it), but would he risk letting loose the monsters again? Nah, I don't think so!
I'd love to see Cas keeping remote tabs on Sam but being there with Dean, proper.
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:24 am (UTC)I think Cas just blipped away to find them a place to hide and regroup.
And yeah, I'm not sure Sam will go the portal route, since that's how they got into the leviathan mess in the first place. Though - I don't know how else he'd do it!
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:28 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:32 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:32 am (UTC)Also, I think partly why Cas and Sam don't have a lot of scenes together might be because they are both pacifists, and there's few things they would clash, unlike Dean, who seems to be so angry nowadays, especially after Hell and Purgatory. I would want a scene of Cas and Sam having an intervention for Dean. It might be interesting.
Also, I'm kinda hoping Sam would end up in Purgatory together with Dean and Cas, and they fight monsters from the inside! LOL My mind, strange place.
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 05:38 am (UTC)But you're right - part of the reason they don't have scenes together is that Sam and Cas actually have a fair bit in common these days...so there's not much clashing going on. Whereas Dean is emotionally stunted. :P Well, Castiel is emotionally stunted too, but in different ways.
I wouldn't mind an epic rescue arc, where Sam has to enter purgatory - fight his way to Dean and Cas - and then they all have to fight their way out. I don't know how the heck that would work though. Also, it'd be a bitch to film, because it would mean the boys would basically have to be out in the woods for months...and that'd be a miserable thing to do in the winter (unless they turned the studio into woods).
no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 12:12 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2012-05-25 06:27 pm (UTC)