For the record (not trying to push it at you or anything) I still recommend it. It is a sort of western/Middle Age knight quest/fantasy in which I could totally see Jensen/Dean as the main character/gunslinger. Dean would be Roland in that world. And Sam would totally fit with another character too... :D I can see why Charlie would like it...

I do not like horror either. But then, Supernatural doesn't really fit the horror genre for me.