Some of this episode was just beautiful. The whole gunfight sequence, the boys in the foggy graveyard, Dean in his hat. I love how even if he's off at the beginning, Dean adapts to his surroundings and makes it work. Kind of like Folsom Prison Blues. This episode had a couple of really cool extra characters. Finch was an interesting MOtW. I thought he was at least as sympathetic as Amy, probably more. Samuel Colt rocked. Dropping Elkins in the story was a nice way to tie up the Colt's history going from hand to hand. The whole bit with Sam and the horse cracks me up, especially because the soundtrack has this drumroll like you hear in execution scenes. I don't know if they stuck it in when they hung Finch. Bobby's question to Cas about running or fighting pretty much echoes Sam's question in the French Mistake when they come through the window. I just loved this episode.