Rec: Fic - From the Ruined Tower to the Caves of Unknown Horror (J2-AU RPS) by Annella

[hells_half_acre]

Check out:

From the Ruined Tower to the Caves of Unknown Horror
by annella 

Word Count: 30,500 
Summary: Jared's been adventuring for most of his life. He loves being out on the road with his friends—killing monsters and bad guys, finding treasure, and helping people out of sticky situations. It's all part of being a good-hearted barbarian. Then his carefree life is shaken up by the introduction of a scrawny half-elf wizard called Jensen, who joins them for a quest upon which they will encounter horror, true friendship, and a secret buried deep underground...

My thoughts in brief:
I haven't been that impressed with this years crop of Big Bangs. Though, I do make it hard for people, since I only like SPN stories that follow canon religious and the flip side of that is that I only like AU J2 (the more AU the better). I also haven't read anything posted in the past three weeks, so who knows what I'm missing.

Regardless though, one story from the stories I've browsed so far has stood out for me! Not because it's a heartwrenching angst filled trip full of pain and misery...but because it's ADORABLE, amusing, and warms the cookies of my heart. It also is a little heartwrenching (but just enough to satisfy). Also, the D&D universe that the story is set in allows for great plot and emotional points that would not be possible in real life.

Further thoughts (not that brief):
In the interest of full-disclosure, I should say that I started playing D&D when I was 21 - a boy (who is now my best friend) introduced it to me. I, like perhaps many of you, thought "D&D is for nerds and dorks!" But I was WRONG. D&D is for story-tellers. Over the years, my best friend and I have told many stories: a dwarf and an elf who shouldn't be best friends, but are; a rogue and cleric who can't stand each other but are forced to work together anyway (and never become friends at all); a brother and sister team (that mirrored the Sam-Dean dynamic before I even saw the show...I played the Dean character...the Sam character was the girl, though she wasn't like Sam at all in personality); and I believe in our final adventure we were a rogue and a wizard, fumbling through adorably clumsy flirting while trying not to die.

So, maybe what stood out about this story is how in keeping it is with D&D. I love the fact that it's told from a kind-hearted barbarian's point of view - because you don't get the angst that comes with over-thinking. Instead you just get the pure emotional responses, and friendship and romance is allowed to follow it's natural progression. 

I also love the fact that although the Jared character is supposed to be the one protecting the Jensen character, from the very start of their adventure we see that it's actually the other way around - with the Jensen character immediately standing-up for the Jared character when Jared is not intelligent enough to know he is being treated poorly (or, rather, is probably so used to being treated poorly because of his low-intelligence, that he doesn't realize he deserves better).

I won't give away the ending, but I will say that the author really knows how to use the rules of D&D to enhance the story.

Comments

[claudiapriscus.livejournal.com]

Well, the amnesia AU I mentioned is following canon and it's based in canon, but it can't exactly return to canon because it's been following season 4 from the beginning- so there are things changing, even if the big stuff stays the same - Lilith, Ruby, the angels and the apocalypse - but the premise had to lead to changes. So it's the same, but different.


The premise-changing ones you mention are not the ones I like - simple reversals, or the slashy stuff, or 'raised evil' - because they don't make sense from the starting premise. The ones I like usually are more along the lines of .... it's a story that could have been told. The writers could have made those decisions. Shifts in the stories, but still true to the premise (and/or the characters). e.g, ratherastory's fic in which stanford!sam is in a very bad accident shortly before the "real" series began- it seems pretty natural for Dean to show up when he gets a phone call that his brother's in a coma (he gets better..ish), so any differences from canon from then on also seem natural (especially as the big things from canon are still lurking out there, and having an impact.)

Then there are those few cool stories where canon from various seasons crash together in cool ways (oh, canonical time travel. It's opened interesting possibilities). There were two big bangs like that this year that I read, and I really liked both.

[hells-half-acre.livejournal.com]

so there are things changing, even if the big stuff stays the same - Lilith, Ruby, the angels and the apocalypse

Yes, these are the types of AUs that I don't mind (and, as you say, can be really good if done well). Basically, much like Samifer, all roads have to lead me to the same destination.

So, I'll accept AUs, but only if the big events stay the same - John dies, there's a special kids showdown in which Sam dies (for instance if the AU does start with Sam being different from the series start - ie: brain-damaged from a coma or in a wheel-chair or something, I don't want it to mean that suddenly YED/Hell writes him out of the plans), Lilith still brings the apocalypse and the boys are still vessels...I'm fine if they want to end Swan Song differently and have them live happily ever after actually, but that's about the only leeway people get on the big events.

So yes, the same but different is fine. It's different and different that annoys me - and makes me less willing to even give AUs a chance in case they don't fit my criteria for acceptable AUs.